LEXIKON
Lawful existence: When old buildings may be lawful even without planning permission
In the case of older buildings, it is often no longer possible to locate the original planning permission. At the latest when the property is sold, extended, converted or subject to building control proceedings, the question then arises as to whether the existing structure is lawful. Section 40 of the Styrian Building Act (Stmk BauG) contains specific rules on this matter. The decisive factors are, above all, the date of construction, the design at the time and any subsequent alterations.
Before 1969: Legality by operation of law
Existing structures erected before 1 January 1969 are deemed lawful under Section 40(1) of the Styrian Building Act (Stmk BauG) if a building permit was required for their construction but cannot be produced. There is no need to examine whether the structure would have been eligible for a permit under the building and regional planning regulations in force at the time. The Administrative Court (VwGH) describes this provision as a statutory presumption of lawfulness; it even covers cases in which a retrospective planning permission has already been refused (VwGH 25 May 2016, Ra 2015/06/0095; www.ris.bka.gv.at/vwgh).
The provision is not limited to construction in the strict sense. Changes of use or alterations requiring planning permission that were carried out before 1 January 1969 may also be covered (VwGH 21 March 2014, 2012/06/0008; www.ris.bka.gv.at/vwgh). The decisive factor is therefore not only whether the building already existed at that time, but also the form in which it was used and the purpose for which it was used.
1969 to 1995: Assessment in accordance with the legal position at the time
A different rule applies to buildings erected between 1 January 1969 and 31 August 1995. Their legality can only be established if they would have been eligible for planning permission at the time of their construction. The assessment must take into account the circumstances at the time and the substantive law in force then, such as the land-use zoning in force at the time or the setback regulations applicable then (VwGH 30 May 2006, 2005/06/0355; www.ris.bka.gv.at/vwgh).
The assessment is carried out either upon application or ex officio in a declaratory procedure. If the conditions are met, the authority issues a decision confirming the lawfulness; this decision also serves as a building and occupancy permit. Changes of use and alterations from this period that were subject to authorisation may also be the subject of the proceedings (VwGH 21 March 2014, 2012/06/0011; www.ris.bka.gv.at/vwgh).
Subsequent alterations must be assessed separately
A subsequent extension or alteration does not automatically render the older part of the building unlawful. If, for example, a building was erected before 1969 and subsequently extended, the original part may still be lawful under Section 40(1) of the Styrian Building Act (Stmk BauG). Alterations carried out between 1 January 1969 and 31 August 1995 must be assessed in accordance with the factual and legal circumstances prevailing at the time. For alterations carried out on or after 1 September 1995, a retrospective planning permission may only be granted in accordance with the legal position in force at the time (Section 40(2a) of the Styrian Building Act; Administrative Court of Austria, 10 July 2025, Case No. 2025/06/0148; www.ris.bka.gv.at/vwgh).
The date of construction must be proven
In practice, reconstructing the existing structure is often the greatest challenge. Historical aerial photographs, photographs, old building plans and submitted plans, contracts, witness statements and expert reports may be considered as evidence. There is no principle whereby, in cases of doubt, the date of construction most favourable to the owner should always be assumed (VwGH 23 November 2010, 2009/06/0093; www.ris.bka.gv.at/vwgh). The owner therefore has a duty to cooperate in providing documents and information that only they can supply.
Conclusion
In the case of older buildings, the absence of a building permit does not therefore necessarily mean that the structure is unlawful. Whether and to what extent Section 40 of the Styrian Building Act (Stmk BauG) applies depends primarily on the date of construction, the design at the time and any subsequent alterations. Clarifying these issues is important not only in the context of building control orders: The granting of planning permission for a subsequent extension or conversion also requires the existing structure to be lawful; whether this is the case may need to be assessed as a preliminary issue during the planning permission process (VwGH 20 June 2002, 2000/06/0124; www.ris.bka.gv.at/vwgh). However, the effect of Section 40 of the Styrian Building Act (Stmk BauG) is limited to building law. It does not replace any necessary authorisations under, for example, trade, water or nature conservation law, and such authorisations must, in principle, be obtained separately. Anyone wishing to sell or alter an existing building should therefore review its building history at an early stage and clarify the necessary authorisations.